By Bob Cropp, Professor Emeritus
University of Wisconsin Cooperative Extension
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Strong cheese and dry whey prices for the month of April will result in a new record high Class III price of about $24.25 for the month. This will be the third straight month of record Class III prices. The Class III price for the first four months of the year will average about $23.12 or $5.65 higher than a year ago. The dry whey price has increased from $0.60-$0.61 per pound to $0.65. Cheese prices have had some rather dramatic price swings during the month. On the CME cheddar barrels started the month at $2.25 per pound, was a low as $2.075 on April 9th, bounced back to $2.28 on April 17th and declined to $2.25 on April 21st. Cheddar blocks started the month at $2.385 per pound, was as high as $2.4225 on April 3rd, reached a low of $2.165 on April 10th, increased to $2.28 on April 14th and declined to $2.25 on April 21st.
These strong cheese prices are the result of good domestic sales, strong exports and lower American cheese production all of which reduced stocks. Cheese exports for the first two months of the year were 44% higher than a year ago. American cheese production for the first two months of the year was 0.2% lower than a year ago. February 28th American cheese stocks declined from January and were 5.0% lower than a year ago. Total cheese stocks on February 28th were also lower than January and were 5.5% lower than a year ago. February 28th dry whey stocks were 13% lower than a year ago the result of 19% lower production for the first two months of the year and 7% more exports.
Little lower butter and nonfat dry milk prices will result in a little lower Class IV price for April. The March Class IV price was $23.66 and the April price will be near $23.20. On the CME butter started the month at $2.01 per pound and has declined to $1.89. Nonfat dry milk was above $2.00 per pound all of March but has been in the high $1.90's since then. For the first four months of the year the Class IV price will average about $23.15 or $5.35 higher than a year ago.
Butter production for the first two months of the year was 3.8% lower than a year ago and exports of butter and milkfat were 113% higher. Butter sales have softened from the prior sales for Easter/Passover. While February 28th butter stocks were 20% higher than January stocks were still 31% lower than a year ago. Nonfat dry milk production for the first two months of the year was just 0.3% lower than a year ago while skim milk powder production for export was up 2.7%. February 28th nonfat dry milk stocks were 19% lower than a year ago.
April prices no doubt will be the peak for the year. Record high milk prices and lower feed costs than a year ago have provided dairy producers with margins conducive to producing more milk. So milk production compared to a year ago will likely increase as we move through the rest of the year. USDA is forecasting total milk production for the year to be 2.4% higher than last year, the result of more milk cows and feeding for higher production per cow. But, this could be on the high side. Rather than expanding cow numbers some producers are using improved margins to pay down debt accumulated during the severely depressed milk prices experienced in 2009 and very high feed prices the fall of 2012 and winter of 2013. And of course how crops turn out this year and resulting feed costs will be an important factor in how producers expand production later this year.
A slowdown in exports could also soften prices. With milk production much improved in New Zealand and the EU-28 countries more dairy products will be available for exports. Prices of butter, cheese, skim milk powder, whole milk powder and milk protein concentrates have already softened considerably in recent international Global Dairy Trades. This decline is lessening the competitive price advantage U.S. has been experiencing on the international market. Yet with the world demand expected to remain strong and world stocks still at low levels U.S. exports for the year could still total 14% to 15% of U.S. milk production. USDA is still forecasting exports on a milkfat basis to actually be 2.4% higher than a year ago with continued good cheese and butter exports, and exports on a skim-solids basis to be down just 2.3%.
Dairy futures remain quite optimistic. Class III futures don't fall below $20 until July and below $19 until October ending in December at $18.30. This compares to an average Class III price for last year of $17.99. Class IV futures don't fall below $20 until August and remain at $19 plus for the remainder of the year ending at $19.12 for December. The Class IV price averaged $19.05 for all of last year. If USDA's increase in milk production comes to bear and exports soften, these prices will be a little optimistic for later in the year. Yet prices substantially lower than current Class III futures are not anticipated. But, we know prices can change rather quickly.
USDA's milk production for the month of March shows a continued modest increase in milk production over a year ago. The estimate for the U.S. is a March increase of 0.9% putting production for the first three months 1.0% higher than a year ago. Since last March USDA was not reporting cow numbers or milk per cow a year ago it is not known how much of the change in milk production was due to changes in cow numbers or milk per cow. U.S. cow numbers started to increase last December and were 3,000 head higher in March than February putting the increase since last November at 20,000. Considering a year ago March milk production for the U.S. was 0.2% lower than the year before the 0.9% increase this March is not a strong increase in milk production.
Comparing March milk production to a year ago amongst the 23 reporting states shows a complete shift from what was going on a year ago. High feed prices resulting in unfavorable margins for producers in the West was resulting in deceases in milk production from a year ago. For example milk production was running 3.3% lower in California and 4.1% lower in Texas with just a 0.4% increase in Idaho. This March milk production is up 3.7% in California, 6.4% in Texas and 1.7% in Idaho. A year ago in the Midwest milk production was running well above a year ago. For example, production was up 4.9% in Iowa, 2.3% in Minnesota and 3.0% in Wisconsin. This year production is down 3.4% in Iowa, 3.8% in Minnesota and 1.6% in Wisconsin. We don't have data as to what is going with cow numbers but lower quality forage and cold weather no doubt negatively impacted milk per cow. The situation is similar in the Northeast with milk production a year ago running 3.5% higher in Michigan, 1.8% higher in New York and 2.3% higher in Ohio. This year production is up just 0.3% for Michigan, no increase for New York and down 4.8% for Ohio.
However, looking ahead we can expect cow numbers to continue to increase and milk per cow to improve particularly in the Midwest and Northeast with a new crop of better quality forages. Producers have already slowed cow slaughter with slaughter numbers through March 9.4% lower than a year ago. But, the growth in increases in milk production will come on slow which could result in USDA's 2.4% increase in milk production for the year being on the high side. And further with this slower growth in milk production milk prices will likely also decline slower.
University of Wisconsin-Madison