Banner
#
#
# # # #

My placing for this class of Holstein cows is C D A B.C places over D for her bloom of udder. C is higher and fuller in her rear udder attachment, wider from the top to the base of her rear quarters, and is smoother in her fore udder attachment than D. C is more balanced in her rear quarters and displays more Holstein breed character about the head and is deeper in the jaw. C displays more overall style and balance, is straighter in the hock, and stands on a stronger pair of pasterns than D. I do grant that D is a longer-bodied individual.
In my middle comparison, D places over A for her size and scale. D is longer-bodied with greater length to her barrel and is longer from hips to pins. D is stronger and more powerful in the front end, being deeper in the heart and deeper in both the fore and rear rib and flank than A. D also is less quartered than A. D blends more smoothly neck to shoulders and is more open in her ribbing. I do concede that A is longer and cleaner in her neck and holds her udder higher above the hock.
Finally, A places over B because of her dairyness. She is longer and leaner in the neck and carries less flesh over the shoulders, topline, and rump. A has more size and scale than B, being a taller, more upstanding individual. She is wider in her hips, thurls, and pins. A has more spring and sweep to the rib. I do grant that B is a smoother blending individual, especially through the front end. However, B lacks the size, scale, and overall dairyness to merit a higher placing.


#About the judge. . .

DOUG WATERMAN, Madison, N.Y., placed the HOLSTEINS. Waterman is director of dairy technology application from Nutreco Canada Agresearch where he is responsible for technology implementation and training programs for Shur Grain and Landmark. While earning a Ph.D. at the University of Kentucky, he coached its dairy judging team for five years. Since 1993, he has coached the New York 4-H dairy judging teams that have consistently done well at national contests and won the 1998 World Dairy Expo. He is co-superintendent of the New York State Fair Dairy Shows and co-superintendent of the NAILE Dairy Judging Contest. He and his wife have two sons.


Scoring Key

HOSTEINS C D A B

CDAB-100 DCAB-92 ACDB-84 BCDA-54
CDBA-90 DCBA-82 ACBD-70 BCAD-50
CADB-96 DACB-80 ADCB-76 BDCA-46
CABD-82 DABC-58 ADBC-54 BDAC-34
CBDA-76 DBCA-60 ABCD-48 BACD-38
CBAD-72 DBAC-48 ABDC-40 BADC-30

NOW AVAILABLE!

##