C-A-D-B is my placing for this class of Brown Swiss. C sorted herself to the top of this class, having the best udder. C places over A on her definite advantage in the udder, having a higher, wider rear udder and showing more fullness at the top of her rear udder. Additionally, C has shorter teats placed more squarely beneath her front quarters. C is also straighter in her hock from the side view and stands on stronger pasterns. I grant that A is sharper over the shoulders and has more spring to her rib.
In a close middle pair, A places over D, having a more youthful mammary system and carrying it higher above her hocks. A has a tighter fore udder as well as a higher rear udder. In addition, A has more width in her front end and carries this width out through her rump. I admit that D stands on a more correct set of feet and legs.
D easily places over B in my bottom pair, using her advantage in dairy character and frame. D is longer from nose to tail, showing more cleanliness throughout, particularly over the rump and down through the thigh. Additionally, D has less quartering between fore and rear quarters and has a more clearly defined median suspensory ligament. While I appreciate the strength of B through the front end, she lacks cleanliness throughout and correctness of udder to merit a higher placing in this class.
About the Judge . . . Jenna Lenhart